A Comparison of Ranking Criteria: an Application to Asset Class Indices of Europe, US, Russia and China


  • Patrizia Stucchi Department of Economics and Statistics University of Udine
  • Alice Spangaro Department of Economics and Statistics University of Udine




Performance measures, Sharpe ratio, Asset class ranking, Skewness, Kurtosis


The main purpose of this work is the ex post comparison of the performances of three macro asset class indices for Europe, United States, Russia and China during the period 2003-2015. The analysis is based on six different ranking criteria, starting with the well-known Sharpe index and its VaR and CVaR modifications, then considering the Omega and Sortino ratios which employ higher partial moments, and at last the Rachev ratio which changes the profitability index. All the previous performance indices give substantially the same ranking; they all show supremacy of Chinese fixed income and both European and American real estate in the years 2003-2008; they indicate US and European stock indices as the worst performers in 2008, and American, Russian and Chinese fixed income indices from 2012 to 2015 again as the worst performers. A visual display of the six different rankings is also provided, highlighting the adequacy of the Sharpe ratio against its more refined alternatives. 


Agarwal V, Naik NY (2004) Risk and portfolio decisions involving hedge funds. Review of Financial Studies 17-1: 63–98

Alexander GJ, Baptista AM (2003) Portfolio Performance Evaluation Using Value at Risk. The Journal of Portfolio Management 29-4 Summer: 93-102

Biglova A, Ortobelli S, Rachev ST, Stoyanov S (2004) Different approaches to risk estimation in portfolio theory. The Journal of Portfolio Management 31-1 Fall: 103-112

Dowd K (2000) Adjusting for risk: An improved Sharpe ratio. International Review of Economics and Finance 9-3: 209–222

Eling M, Schuhmacher F (2007) Does the choice of performance measure influence the evaluation of hedge funds? Journal of Banking & Finance 31: 2632–2647

Rachev ST Ed (2003) Handbook of Heavy Tailed Distributions in Finance. Elsevier

Rachev ST, Martin D, Racheva-Iotova B, Stoyanov S (2009) Stable ETL optimal portfolios and extreme risk management. In Risk Assessment Physika Verlag: 235-262

Shadwick WF, Keating C (2002) A universal performance measure. Journal of Performance Measurement 6 -3: 59–84

Sharpe WF (1966) Mutual fund performance. Journal of Business 39-1: 119–138

Sharpe WF (1994) The Sharpe Ratio. The Journal of Portfolio Management 21-1 Fall: 49-58

Sortino FA, van der Meer R (1991) Downside risk. The Journal of Portfolio Management 17-4 Spring: 27–31