Research on Poverty in Transition Economies: A Meta-analysis on Changes in the Determinants of Poverty


  • Kumo Kazuhiro Institute of Economic Research, Hitotsubashi University, Japan



Poverty, Transition Economies, Meta-Analysis, Systematic Survey


Research on the increase in poverty in the transitional economies affected by the collapse of socialism began soon after the economic transition began. However, the nature of poverty in the former Soviet Union and Central and Eastern Europe differs, and two phases have been observed: a phase of increasing and stabilising poverty in the 1990s and a phase of declining poverty in the 2000s. Taking into account the possibility that the impact of household size, education level, and urban domicile, which are factors employed in traditional poverty research, may differ depending on the year or the region, this paper attempted a meta-analysis.
The results enerally supported the hypothesis. In the 1990s, there was no difference between urban and rural populations in the probability of falling into poverty. After 2000, however, urban domicile became a significant factor in reducing the probability of falling into poverty. In addition, differences were observed between the former Soviet Union and Central and Eastern Europe in the factors affecting the poverty situation. This phenomenon is considered to indicate one of the directions for research in comparative transitional economics in the future. Furthermore, the trend in poverty dynamics seen here can probably also be regarded as indicating steady progress in “transition”.


Download data is not yet available.


Akhmedjonov A. (2011) Do Higher Levels of Education Raise Earnings in Post-Reform Russia? Eastern European Economics, vol.49 (4): 47–60

Alexandrova A, Hamilton E, Kuznetsova P (2006) What Can Be Learned from Introducing Settlement Typology into Urban Poverty Analysis: The Case of the Tomsk Region, Russia, Urban Studies, vol.43 (7): 1177–1189

Bellaka C, Leibrechtb M, Liebensteinerc M (2013) Short-term Labour Migration from the Republic of Armenia to the Russian Federation, Journal of Development Studies, vol.50 (3): 349–367

Bezemer D, Lerman Z (2004) Rural Livelihoods in Armenia, Post-Communist Economies, vol.16 (3): 333–348

Bhaumik S, Gang I, Yun M (2006) Ethnic Conflict and Economic Disparity: Serbians and Albanians in Kosovo, Journal of Comparative Economics, vol.34, pp.754–773

Bhaumik S, Gang I, Yun M (2006) A Note on Poverty in Kosovo, Journal of International Development, vol.18, pp.1177–1187

Bisogno M, Chong A (2001) Foreign Aid and Poverty in Bpsnia and Herzegovina: Targeting Simulations and Policy Implications, European Economic Review, vol.45, pp.1020–1030

Bobkov V (2007) ed, Kachestvo i uroven zhizni naseleniya v novoi Rossii, Vserossiiskii tsentr urovnya zhisni, Moscow. (in Russian)

Borenstein M, Hedges L, Higgins J, Rothstein H (2009) Introduction to Meta-Analysis, Wiley

Bradford M, Mykerezib E (2009) Chronic and transient poverty in the Russian Federation, Post-Communist Economies, vol.21 (3): 283–306

Braithwaite J (1995) The Old and New Poor in Russia: Trends in Poiverty, ESP Discussion Paper Series 21227, World Bank

Braithwaite J, Grootaert C, Milanovic B (2000) Poverty and Social Assistance in Transition Countries, Macmillan, London

Brück T, Danzer A, uravyev A, Weisshaar N (2011) Poverty During Transition: Household Survey Evidence from Ukraine, Journal of Comparative Economics, vol. 38, pp.123–145

Commander S, Tolstopiatenko A, Yemtsov R (1999) Channels of Redistribution: Inequality and Poverty in the Russian Transition, Economics of Transition, vol.7 (2): 411–447

Dimova R, Wolff F (2008) Are Private Transfers Poverty and Inequality Reducing? Household Level Evidence from Bulgaria, Journal of Comparative Economics, vol.36, pp.584–598

Fialova K, Mysikova M (2009) Labour Market Participation: The Impact of Social Benefits in the Czech Republic and Selected European Countries, Prague Economic Papers, no.3, pp.235–250

Gerry C, Nivorozhkin E, Rigg J (2008) The Great Divide: 'Ruralisation' of Poverty in Russia, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol.32 (4): 593–607

Gerry C, Carmen L (2010) Consumption Smoothing and Vulnerability in Russia, Applied Economics, vol.42, pp.1995–2007

Giddings L (2003) Continued Decline for Ethnic Minorities in the Transition? Changes in Ethnic Earnings Differentials in Bulgaria, 1986, 1993 and 1997, Economics of Transition, vol.11 (4): 621–648

Gustafsson B, Nivorozhkina L (2004) Changes in Russian Poverty during Transition as Assessed from Microdata from the City of Taganrog, Economics of Transition, vol.12 (4): 747–776

Habibov N (2011) Public Beliefs Regarding the Causes of Poverty during Transition: Evidence from the Caucasus, Central Asia, Russia, and Ukraine, International Journal of Sociology & Social Policy, vol.31 (1/2): 53–74

Habibov N (2012) How and Why Determinants of Hosehold Welfare Changed in Azerbaijan During the Transition, Problems of Economic Transition, vol.54 (11): 3–52

Hoti A (2011) Returns for Education in Kosovo: Estimates of Wage and Employment Premia, South East European Journal of Economics and Business, vol.6 (1): 71–84

Iwasaki I, Tokunaga M (2013) Gaikoku Shihon to Taisei Tenkan: Shijou Keizai-ka 20 Nen Shi no Meta-bunseki [Foreign Capital and Transition: A Meta-analysis of the 20 Years Since the Beginning of the Transition to a Market Economy], Economic Review, vol.64 (4):353–378

Iwasaki I, Tokunaga M (2014) Gaikoku Chokusetsu Toushi to Seisansei Hakyuu Kouka: Ikou Keizai Kenkyuu no Meta-bunseki [Foreign Direct Investment and the Ripple Effect on Productivity: A Meta-analysis of Studies in Transition Economics], Comparative Economic Research, vol.51, no.2, pp.1–29.

Jha R, Dang T (2009) Vulnerability to Poverty in Select Central Asian Countries, European Journal of Comparative Economics, vol.6 (1): 17–50.

Jha R, Tu D, Tashrifov Y (2010) Economic Vulnerability and Poverty in Tajikistan, Economic Change and Restructuring, vol.43 (2): 95–112

Kecmanovic M (2012) Men’s Wage Inequality in Serbia’s Transition, Economic Systems, vol.36, pp.65–86

Kolev A (2005) Unemployment, Job Quality and Poverty: A Case Study of Bulgaria, International Labour Review, vol.144 (1): 85–114

Kristic G, Sanfey P (2007) Mobility, Poverty and Well-being Among the Informally Employed in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Economic Systems, vol.31, pp.311–335

Lacroix,G, Radtchenko N (2011) The Changing Intra-household Resource Allocation in Russia, Journal of Population Economics, vol.24 (1): 85–106

Lokshin M, Ravallion M (2004) Household Income Dynamics in Two Transition Economies, Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics and Econometrics, vol.8 (3), article 4

Lokshin M (2009) A Survey of Poverty Research in Russia: Does It Follow the Scientific Method? Economic Systems, vol.33 (3): 191–212

McAuley A (1979) Economic Welfare in the Soviet Union: Poverty, Living Standards, and Equality, University of Wisconsin Press, George Allen & Unwin.

Milanovic B (1997) Income, Inequality, and Poverty during the Transition from Planned to Market Economy, World Bank.

Milcher S, Zigova K (2005) Evidence of Returns to Education: Among Roma in Central and Eastern Europe and Their Policy Implications, Managing Global Transitions, vol.3 (1): 51–69

Mills B, Mykerezi E (2009) Chronic and Transient Poverty in the Russian Federation, Post-Communist Economies, vol.21 (3): 283–306

Mullen B (1989) Advanced Basic Meta-Analysis, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

Nivorozhkin E, Nivorozhkin A, Nivorozhkina L, Ovcharova L (2010) The Urban-Rural Divide in the Perception of the Poverty Line: the Case of Russia, Applied Economics Letters, vol.17 (16): 1543–1546

Pastore F, Verashchagina A (2006) The Distribution of Wages in Belarus, Comparative Economic Studies, vol.48, pp.351–376

Ravallion M, Chen S, Sangraula P (2007) New Evidence on the Urbanization of Global Poverty, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 4199

Razumov A, Yagodkina M (2007) Bednost v sovremennoi Rossii, Formula prava, Moscow. (in Russian).

Rhoe V, Babu S, Reidhead W (2008) An Analysis of Food Security and Poverty in Central Asia: Case Study from Kazakhstan, Journal of International Development, vol.20, pp.452–465

Robinson S, Guenther T (2007) Rural Livelihoods in Three Mountainous Regions of Tajikistan, Post-Communist Economies, vol.19 (3) 359–378

Ruminska-Zimny E (1997) Human Poverty in Transition Economies: Regional Overview for HDR 1997, Human Development Report Office, United Nations Development Programme.

Szulc A (2006) Poverty in Poland during the 1990s: Are the Results Robust? Review of Income and Wealth, vol.52 (3): 423–448

Szulc A (2008) Checking the Consistency of Poverty in Poland: 1997-2003 Evidence, Post-Communist Economies, vol.20 (1) 33–55

Verme P (2011) The Poverty Reduction Capacity of Public and Private Transfers in Transition, Journal of Development Studies, vol.47 (6): 870–893



How to Cite

Kazuhiro, K. (2016). Research on Poverty in Transition Economies: A Meta-analysis on Changes in the Determinants of Poverty. Journal Transition Studies Review, 23(1), 37-59.