Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Crisis of Diplomatic Etiquette and the 2015 African Union Summit in South Africa: Is the International Criminal Court at Crossroads on Omar-Bashir’s arrest?

Daniel Taye Medoye, Mark I. Rieker

Abstract


The role of the International Criminal Court (ICC) became a subject of intense debate during the African Union Summit held in June 2015 and hosted by South Africa. Opinions varied among scholars and experts, as well as commentators on whether the Treaty-based international organisation located in the Hague, Netherlands, had the enforceable rights to subject African leaders to trials arising from accusations of genocide, crime against humanity and war crimes and related issues. Against this background, this paper set out to examine the implications of the unsettling diplomatic imbroglio between South Africa and the ICC on the non-compliance of the country with the Court’s request for the arrest of President Omar Bashir of Sudan on charges of genocide and crimes against humanity. Having examined the legal and diplomatic relationship between the ICC and member states in terms of duties and obligations respectively, this paper submits that Court has both enforceable and moral rights to subject any African leader to trials if and when formal accusations of the crimes as mentioned earlier, are established against them. This position is without prejudice to the issue of immunity enjoyed by African leaders in their respective countries. It is a norm and widely acknowledged though, that membership of any multilateral organisation in the contemporary international system requires the giving up of some sovereign right to effective policy implementation for the benefit of members.


Keywords


Diplomatic Etiquette; International Criminal Court; Genocide; Immunity; Jurisdiction

Full Text:

PDF

References


Al Jazeera and Reuters (2015) South Africa to review ICC membership after Bashir crisis, accessed online at, http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2015/06/after-review-icc-membership-bashir-srisis-150625084934936.html

Articles of the Rome Statutes (in sequence and italicised in this paper to indicate the articles have been quoted as in the Statute online) – 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12 and 27

Bah AS (2010) The African Union in Darfur: Understanding the Afro-Arab Response to the Crisis, FRIDE, A European Think Tank for Global Action, accessed online at, http://fride.org/download/OP_Responses_arab_world_ENG_feb10.pdf

BBC News (2015) Profile: Sudan’s Omar al-Bashir, accessed online at, http://www.bbc.com.news/world-africa-16010445

Bensouda F (2015) South Africa had to arrest Omar al-Bashir, accessed online at, http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes.talktojazeera/2015/06/fatou-bensouda-africa-arrest-omar-al-bashir-150626132631885.htmls.

Bowd R, Chikwanha AB (2010) Understanding Africa’s Contemporary Conflicts: Origins, challenges and Peacebuilding, Institute of Security Studies, Monograph 173, accessed online at http://www.issafrica.org/uploads/Mono173.pdfHuman Rights Watch, 2015, accessed online at, http://www.hrw.org/topic/international-sjustice/international-criminal-court.

Infoplease on Sudan, 2007, U.S. Department of State Background Note, http://www.infoplease.com/country/profiles/sudan.html

International Criminal Court (ICC), 2009, ICC Prosecutor presents case against Sudanese President, Hassan Ahmad AL BASHIR, for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes in Darfur, accessed online at, ICC Prosecutor presents case against Sudanese President, Hassan Ahmad AL BASHIR, for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes in Darfur

Keith A (2007) The African Union in Darfur: An African Solution to a Global Problem? , accessed online at, http://princeton.edu/jpia-issues-1/2007/7.pdf

Khadiagala GM (2015) Why a great deal hangs on Al-Bashir’s fate in South Africa, The Conversation – The Pilot, accessed online at, www.theconversation.com/why-a great-deal-hangs-on-al-bashirs-fate-in-south-africa-43229

Maru MT (2015) Why South Africa let Bashir get Away, accessed online at, http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2015/06/south-africa-bashir-150615102211840.html

Owoeye J, Amusan L (2000) Sub-regionalisation of Internal War in Africa with Reference to the Congo Crisis, Ife Social Sciences Review, Obafemi Awolowo Universisty, Vol.18, No.1

Paulat L (2015) Does Africa Need its Own International Criminal Court to escape Bias?, accessed online at, http://www.care2.com.causes/does-africa-need-its-own-international-criminal-court-to-escape-bias.htmls

Sikanga A (2009) The World’s Humanitarian Crisis: Understanding the Darfur Conflict, Vol.2, Issue 5, accessed online at, http://origins.osu.edu/article.worlds-worst-humanitarian-crisis-understanding-darfur-conflict,

Sudan Net (2011) Facts on Sudan, accessed online at, http://www.sudan.net/facts.php

Taffo, FF, 2015, The Hissene Habre Case, African Centre for the Constructive Resolution of Disputes (ACCORD), accessed online at http://www.accord.org.za/conflict-trends/the-hissene-habre-case/

United Human Rights Council (2015) Genocide in Darfur, accessed online at, http://www.unitedhumanrights.org/genocide/genocide-in-sudan.htm

Zeleza PT (2008) The Causes and Costs of War in Africa: From Liberation Struggles to the “War on Terror”, accessed online at, http://www.ohioswallow.com/extras/9780821418093_intro.pdf




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.14665/1614-4007-24-1-006

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


"Transition Studies Review" ISSN online 1614-4015 / ISSN print 1614-4007

All publishing rigths reserved to © Transition Academia Press. Executive editor: Prof. Dr. Giorgio Dominese